ADSD with SOAAOA and Udi – Day 3

Dear diary, today is day 12 of my 5-Day Training Course.

I would complain about the energy drain if not for the appreciation that Udi is investing so much of his time. Every day starts at 8:30, and goes well past 6 pm with very limited breaks. It’s a … marathon? (I hope?) We’re now 30 hours in with at least 20 more to go that I can tell, excluding further homework tomorrow.

I am a bit mystified why Udi uses the word “Service” so much when he clearly has a distaste for its nebulous definition and general appropriation. “Authority Oriented Architecture” sounds like a much better descriptor overall, even if Authority isn’t ideally unambiguous either.

IT managed to go through all the good words by the end of last century, re-defining them all into meaninglessness.

The pattern in Udi’s style is abundantly clear by now; cleverly selected examples without singular answers, and a well-honed skill at arguing, together make for a lot of head-scratching around the room. I am enjoying thinking around the provocative propositions he throws out there, but I cannot help but feel there’s a level of empty calories about the exercise.

There will be no technology advice anywhere along the way. That’s an implementation-detail that is case-specific and therefore not something he can (or will) give us. I think some in the class are still hoping/thinking we may end up there, but that’s not the direction this course is following.

There will also be no scientific underpinnings for the theories. De-composing architecture along the lines of his advice is a good thing, because. And by squinting just right I am convinced overall that’s true, but I wish I had something more concrete to hang that on. Case studies. Empirical evidence. A rigid mathematical proof (I can dream…), but that’s also not where this is heading.

It’s a very valuable exercise at stretching the mind, and learning new ways to approach architectural and design decisions though, and that’s not to be sneezed at.

Still no silver bullets, sadly.

One thought on “ADSD with SOAAOA and Udi – Day 3”

  1. I suspect my assessment sounds more negative both than I intended and than is warranted.

    And I cannot decide whether I want to send all the Devs to this course, or keep it far far away from them. If the vigorous questioning and discussion in class is any indication it could result in constant vigorous questioning and discussion at work 😉

Comments are closed.